Copilot as the New Troublehooter?

Do I want this, really?

https://www.infopackets.com/news/11709/ms-wants-copilot-ai-diagnose-win11-problems

This came to my mailbox late yesterday, from Infopackets. 

I'll admit my first reaction was, "Sure. Sure I want MS's AI roaming on my computer at all, never mind sifting through everything disguised as a troubleshooter." That's because I'm a trusting soul. Then, I thought to myself, is looking up some 0x000xxx code and then manually searching for a trusted solution that isn't a virus disguised as helper software any better?

MS supposedly wants to make things consensual, easier and better with a local agent and cloud support (if needed). Sounds nice, because this is potentially better than getting a generic list of possible causes and having to do the differential diagnosis (in medical jargon).

I suggest referring to the article linked above because it isn't right to scrape. 

Some good points? Well, not everyone is computer savvy and potentially, this could save those folks and others from falling into Support racket traps, etc. It won't repair things automatically  It will have a "Read only" option, MS says at this point and this thing is far from launching, btw. It would tell one where the problem lies and let you fix it yourself.  The diagnostic tool is best understood as an AI-powered troubleshooting assistant rather than an automatic repair tool. 

The nitty gritty: Trust. MS says you will have to consent to have Copilot access "relevant local information" basically, Quis custodem custodit? or, "Who guards the guardian? 

"The new feature is intended to perform its diagnostic analysis locally, taking advantage of AI processing capabilities built into Copilot+ PCs. This reduces the need to transmit certain diagnostic information to remote servers. However, that does not necessarily mean every Copilot interaction will remain completely offline.

Microsoft's broader Hybrid Intelligence approach allows tasks to use local or cloud-based AI depending on the operation. Users should therefore distinguish between a locally executed diagnostic scan and other Copilot features that may require Internet connectivity. It's also important to remember that giving an AI assistant access to system information carries privacy considerations, even when that access is authorized.

For example, diagnostic information may reveal details about connected hardware, software configurations, and the computer's operating environment. Before enabling these capabilities, users should review the permissions being requested and understand what information Copilot can access. (Source: techradar.com)" -Infopackets

So far this is only for computers with an NPU. MS hasn't spoken about older computers.

Finally, is this better than MS's old trouble shooters? Maybe, maybe not. Remember, AI "answers" aren't necessarily correct, so we're back to "better for experienced users"...but wasn't this supposed to be better for the inexperienced user??? 

"Determining the actual cause may require testing outside Windows. Users should therefore exercise caution before following recommendations that involve changing system configurations, modifying the Windows Registry, uninstalling drivers, or deleting files.

Creating a restore point or maintaining a reliable backup remains advisable before making significant system changes." - Infopackets

Now there's a revelation, right? I don't know, but to me, the more things change, the more they seem to be the same. 

Maybe it can help, but I think AI by its very nature is supposed to emulate human thinking, and who likes saying (or hearing), "I don't know."?

If I've left you feeling confused, welcome to the club.

 

20 views 0 replies