Felt like I kept up ok though, but fell behind here and there. He was spot on with the jungle timers for red and I compensated as I could. One time I knew he used smite to steal my red like a jerk, so I went right back at him and stole his blue right in front of him and then ran like a bitch (a dragon bitch). Anyway, I think karls a good jungler and don't think I could have kept up with him as much without all the time I've been putting into jangle. Was nice to see I've learned some anyway.
You had good buff control, and a good mid game when our team was really disorganized.
But, the laning phase didn't go well for you at all IMO. Your never did successfully set up a play in the laning phase. Your first gank on mid was good and you did what you could there, but after that you just weren't putting any pressure on our lanes, and our lanes were pushed. Your only real gank attempts were these odd followup plays where I'd gank somewhere and then you'd try ganking the same spot about 5 seconds after I left. That doesn't work because I can just turn around and stop that.
I'm not saying that I had a huge volume of ganks or anything (I didn't end up doing much in the laning phase either), but I at least set up a couple of positive plays, usually with help from mid.
Your real problem is that you have to realize that you really don't want Nasus sitting top and just free farming his SS. So you should have been camping the crap out of top, especially since it was on your red side. If you let the game go very long, you get to the point where he is too farmed for you+shen to do anything...which is very bad for you.
Now, you might say that you weren't ganking much because Shy doesn't have the strongest ganks. Fair enough. But why take somebody who is a jungle bully when you know you are playing against somebody who will just pick somebody who you can't bully? Then you don't have strong ganks and can't bully, so there isn't much left. If you wanted to play Shy against us, you need to ban Udyr since you could have reasonably bullied my other junglers.
Also, your play at my blue wasn't that smart given your knowledge. You are going into a case with a neutral position top and a pushed mid, meaning that we can get superior numbers to you first. And you are letting me take you down to 60% health to start. If I had mana, you would have at least had to flash and if I had a flash, you were probably dead. You were fortunate in that I didn't have mana, but you didn't know that ahead of time.
Also, press tab more. Is Nasus buying a lot of wards or not? These are things that you need to know.