Forum Home | Login

jazzilady

Join Date 07/2002

+93

who rates the wallpapers?

Ratings

I was just wondering about the wallpaper ratings. I've seen a lot of wallpapers that have 5 stars on them and they aren't that great! I've seen some with 2&3 stars that I thought were a lot better. How do you rate them and who does the rating? Just something I've wondered about for a long time now. I'm not trying to complain about anyone's work, I'm just curious!

wallpapers

Locked Post

Advanced Search

Watch this post

Do not email me updates for this post Email me updates for this post

Successfully updated karma reason!

2of3

Join Date 10/2006

+816

Wallpapers submitted by for example you and I are auto rated at 3 stars because they don't go through moderation. Then it's up to users to rate them up or down. Others are rated initially by a moderator where they need at least a 2 star rating to go into the public gallery.

Successfully updated karma reason!

kenwas

Join Date 04/2003

+124

I think the moderators sometimes also rate those that are auto approved even though they don't have to for moderation sake.

Successfully updated karma reason!

Disturbedcomputer

Join Date 02/2007

+137

so what about the new stars they now have 2 each, so dose one star now = 2 or do you still have to have 2 stars = 4???

Successfully updated karma reason!

Sign Up or Login and this ad disappears!
There are many great features available to you once you register. Sign Up for a free account and browse the forums without ads.

kenwas

Join Date 04/2003

+124

One star equals two points on a scale of ten but there are now also 1/2 stars which you will notice if you select carefully.

Successfully updated karma reason!

Disturbedcomputer

Join Date 02/2007

+137

so it takes 4 points to pass? to public view...a.k.a. 2 stars

cause I have 5-6 points on some from the mods and are not in the public view a.k.a. 2 1/2 - 3 stars

not whining just asking

Successfully updated karma reason!

kenwas

Join Date 04/2003

+124

Every submittal that gets to the public galleries begins with a 3 star rating and goes up or down from there.

Successfully updated karma reason!

kenwas

Join Date 04/2003

+124

Don't misunderstand me, I personally think the system is as useless as the karma system. I am just telling you how it works as far as I know.

Successfully updated karma reason!

Thank you Ken, I agree!

Successfully updated karma reason!

Frankief

Join Date 09/2003

+295

Jazzi, don't let the stars get in your eyes! The download count is the true rating of any work submitted!

Successfully updated karma reason!

I agree completely with franki ...jazzilady.its the wallpaper downloads that count.

Successfully updated karma reason!

WOM

Join Date 01/2002

+253

Nope, we don't rate JM's and above. There rating as Tim said get a bogus 3 star rating just for show. The first person that rates it , that will be the rating it will have till someone else rates it and then it will be equaled in.

Successfully updated karma reason!

Frankie, Devjit, you're right! That is true, but it gets discouraging sometimes when you've put so much time and effort into a wallpaper and it comes up with 2 stars! Maybe I'm just too sensative, but it kinda hurts!

Successfully updated karma reason!

Frankief

Join Date 09/2003

+295

Quoting jazzilady,

reply 12

Trust me dear, I know just how you feel but I have had to put those same feelings of hurt and disapointment aside and go with the downloads. Some folks are just malicious and get some sort of evil pleasure downgrading stuff. I know this for a fact because I have seen five stars turn into two in a matter of an hour, but downloads don't lie. If folks like it, they will download it but they don't always rate it.

Successfully updated karma reason!

Snowman

Join Date 03/2001

+343

Sad....

Seeing a few here, saying "never mind the ratings", but still they have bitched and whined about their own low ratings in the passed....

Successfully updated karma reason!

Frankief

Join Date 09/2003

+295

https://www.wincustomize.com/explore/wallpapers/43700/

Perfect example, went from five stars to one in ten minutes. This has got to be some sort of abuse of the ratings but the downloads are great even with the broken links. Sad doesn't begin to cover it! I say one would have a right to complain if this is the case. Yes, it does hurt to know someone is deliberately skewing the ratings!

Successfully updated karma reason!

Nimbin

Join Date 01/2006

+118

The star rating is less than useless as far as i am concerned. Some people who upload have fanclubs who will rate their work up just because they like the person and the ratings have nothing to do with the quality of the work. While i can understand this type of behaviour it really does nothing to encourage those people to grow and get better. My advice is to upload and share for yourself and if people like it they will download it. As long as your happy with your work thats all that really matters.

Successfully updated karma reason!

Perfect example, went from five stars to one in ten minutes. This has got to be some sort of abuse of the ratings but the downloads are great even with the broken links.

Hey Frankief; this rating drop may be a result of someone frustrated about the broken link.

As for the great downloads, since the link is broken there are actually no downloads and every time anyone clicks download and gets the error message it is still getting counted. Four of the download count is from me, if download was working I could download many times but it would only show as one unique download and the rest would show under total downloads overall on the expanded downloads stats page (click on download count to see this). Unique count is the count that shows on the skins page and your stats page.

Successfully updated karma reason!

I appreciate everyones advice very much! I guess I'd better get less niave about how people are and stop thinking everyone is nice. I take everything to heart, and I need to stop doing that! Anyway, you guys are really special and I thank you for the advice.

Successfully updated karma reason!

Frankief

Join Date 09/2003

+295

Well, thanks to Hankers the broken links have been fixed, apparently it was the # in the file name causing a corrupted zip file. If I accused someone falsely, I apologize, but I have seen this happen repeatedly in the past where the rating changes drastically in a short period of time and was always able to counter this with the download number. I suppose the numbers will be skewed due to the bad zip file.

Jazzi Dear, this is real life and unfortunately everyone is not nice but I would hope the percentage of nice is higher than the percentage of naughty. You gotta get tough and don't wear your heart on your sleeve! I am a big one to talk! I cry if you look at me crooked!

Successfully updated karma reason!

Thanks Frankie, I've gotten a lot better than I used to be though! Sort of reminds me of when I made a right turn to come home, had my blinkers on and everything. The guy in back of me flipped me off, for absolutely no reason! I'm still crushed over that one! What a crazy world!

Successfully updated karma reason!

DrJBHL

Join Date 04/2002

+4137

Ladies....you both are superb artists.You both rate 'Tops' in my book (if that counts for anything).

Have you ever considered that those 'ratings' (especially the low ones) are given by people with no talent to create original works? They might just be rating works which are beautiful out of spite.

jazzilady, you live in less than a perfect world....with angry people. Let it go...and move on.

Successfully updated karma reason!

Ratings, download count, Who cares?

Just because something has a high download count does not mean everyone who downloaded it is going to use it or even like it.

As for the ratings, they could go away as far as I am concerned. To many people get all upset over nothing but how many stars there work has.

To me the only thing that should matter to the artist is how they feel about there own work, not what everybody else thinks.If people think it is good they will comment on how good it is and not by how many stars it is worth.

If and when I upload something and it only gets a half a star or just a couple downloads, I could care less as long as I am happy with the work I had done!

Successfully updated karma reason!

Frankief

Join Date 09/2003

+295

Thanks Doc! You are a sweetheart. It counts for a lot in my little book!

Successfully updated karma reason!

Yes, you're very right DrJBHL, I never thought of it that way. I guess I've always cared too much what others think of me and it shouldn't matter at all. Ok! Darn it anyway! I'm lettin it go now. Heiger, you're right too, and Frankie, we're that good, aren't we?

Successfully updated karma reason!

Quoting jazzilady,

reply 24

we're that good, aren't we?

YES, you are!!

Successfully updated karma reason!

Welcome Guest! Please take the time to register with us.

There are many great features available to you once you register, including:

Richer content, access to many features that are disabled for guests like commenting and posting on the forums.
Access to a great community, with a massive database of many, many areas of interest.
Access to contests & subscription offers like exclusive emails.
It's simple, and FREE!

View all recent posts

Mark all posts as read Delete cookies created by the forum Return to Top

Stardock Forums v Server Load Time: Page Render Time: