And why, pray tell do you consider my comments 'irrational'?
You, in the crusade against piracy, would have me watch fewer shows legally.
If I am not, and never will be a customer, which was the case for several television shows, including Heroes, TSC, Chuck, Fringe, and Warehouse 13, they can only gain by my illegally obtaining a copy of a previously aired show to see if I want to watch the series.
I have not, and never will become a viewer of something I've not seen from the start. I pirated at least one previously aired show from everything I've mentioned with the exception of Warehouse 13. I'll start a torrent of episode 2 in a few minutes assuming I can find it. I caught a re-run if the premier last night and liked it well enough to catch up on Hulu, which has 3 and up currently. I've legally watched every successive episode from those other series. I'm even collecting Chuck on DVD, which is a first, and possibly a last.
It works like this, I ignore the commercials for some lame ass looking television show, and a month later some other dumbass with a low threshold for commercials says "Hey man, are you watching show X? It's actually good!" First I look for a legal means to verify that, then I look for an illegal means if I can work up the motivation to do it.
Short of time travel, your commentary doesn't fit. I can't go back and watch episode 2 of Warehouse 13 when it aired on that unmentionably stupid station who's name I hate thinking about. When I "steal" it, if I can work up the motivation off this reminder(torrents and satellite internet just do not mix...), that is the only way I will end up watching further episodes on the first airing, when they make the most of it.